Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout06470Rev. 5/27/99 ORDINANCE NO. 6470 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE XVII OF THE PUEBLO MUNICIPAL CODE RELATING TO TELECOMMUNICATIONS TOWERS AND ANTENNAS, PERMITTED LOCATIONS THEREFOR, PERFORMANCE STANDARDS THEREFOR, AND SPECIAL USE PERMITS THEREFOR BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF PUEBLO, that: (Brackets indicate matter being deleted; underscoring indicates new matter being added.) SECTION 1 Section 17 -2 -1 of Chapter 2, Title XVII of the Pueblo Municipal Code, as amended, is amended by the addition of new subsections (6.1.1), (6.1.2), (6.3.05), (16.3), (16.5), (38.5), and (63.01) and by amending subsection (24) thereof, to read as follows: Sec. 17 -2 -1. Definitions. For the purpose of this Title, certain terms or words used herein shall be interpreted as follows: 6.1.1 Alternative tower structure means man-made trees, clock towers, bell steeples, ight poles and similar alternative - design mounting structures that camouflage or conceal the presence of antennas or towers. 6.1.2 Antenna means any exterior transmitting or receiving, device mounted on a tower, building or structure and used in communications that radiate or capture electromagnetic waves, digital signals. analog sign, radio frequencies (excluding radar signals), wireless communications signals or other communication signals. 6.3.05 Backhaul network means the lines that connect a telecommunications provider's towers /cell sites to one or more cellular telephone switching offices, and /or long distance providers, or the public switched telephone network. 16.3 FAA means the Federal Aviation Administration. 16.5 FCC means the Federal Communications Commission. (24) Height, building means the vertical distance from the grade to the highest point of the coping of a flat roof, to the deck line of a mansard roof or to the average height of the highest gable of a pitch or hip roof. Height means, when referring to a tower or other antenna structure. the distance measured from the finished grade of the parcel to the hi hest point on the tower or other structure, including the base pad and anv antenna. U8.5 Preexisting towers and preexisting antennas means anv tower or antenna for which a building hermit or special use permit has been properly issued prior to the effective date of the Ordinance adopting Article VI of Chapter 4 of this Title, including permitted towers or antennas that have not vet been constructed so long, as such approval is current and not ex it d. 63.01 Tower (Antenna) means any structure that is designed and constructed primarily for the purpose of supporting one or more antennas for telephone. radio and similar communication purposes, including, self-supporting lattice towers. guyed towers. or monopole towers. The term includes radio and television transmission towers, microwave towers. common - carrier towers. cellular telephone towers, alternative tower structures. and the like. The term includes the structure and anv support thereto. SECTION 2 Section 17 -4 -25 of Chapter 4, Title XVII of the Pueblo Municipal Code, as amended, is amended to read as follows: Sec. 17 -4 -25. Exceptions to height regulations. The height limitations contained in the Schedule of District Regulations do not apply to spires, belfiies, cupolas, [antennas,] water tanks, ventilators, chimneys or other appurtenances usually required to be placed above the roof level and not intended for human occupancy, except as otherwise provided in S -2 districts. Towers (Antenna) and antennas are subject to the specific height limitations and other restrictions set forth in Section 17 -4 -61 through 17 -4- -2- 69 of this Title. SECTION 3 Section 17 -4 -30 of Chapter 4, Title XVII of the Pueblo Municipal Code, as amended, is amended to read as follows: Sec. 17 -4 -30. Public utilities. W For purposes of all districts, a public utility is defined to be a water, irrigation, sewer, gas, electric, telephone, bus, taxi, ambulance or railroad system or installation which serves five (5) or more customers, whether or not it is franchised or organized as a corporation or district. Public utility installations shall be subject to the following requirements: (1) Distribution, transmission and service lines and routes requiring simple easements or installation in public rights -of -way or installed under franchise agreement with the City and /or County and usual customer facilities shall not be subject to zoning requirements. (2) Utility service facilities, the major use of which involves either office, manufacturing, warehousing, retailing, vehicle storage or maintenance functions, shall be constructed only in those zone districts in which a private firm not in the utility business would be permitted to establish a similar function or use. (3) Special utility facilities, such as water reservoirs, sewage lagoons, switching yards, pumping stations and other component equipment installations on land owned or leased and where the equipment is fenced or placed in a building shall not be con- structed until a special use permit has been issued by the Zoning Board of Appeals. (4) These regulations shall in no way prohibit the installation of temporary facilities of the types described in subsections (2) and (3) above in cases of emergency conditions, provided that, within a reasonable period of time, application is made for approval of installation of permanent facilities. Neither wireless telecommunications providers, nor the towers antennas or other facilities used by wireless telecommunications providers, shall be considered as a public utility for purposes of this Title. -3- SECTION 4 Section 17 -4 -51 of Chapter 4, Title XVII of the Pueblo Municipal Code, as amended, is amended by amending the following paragraphs of subsections thereof, to wit: paragraph c. of subsection (1), paragraph c. of subsection (11. 1), paragraph c. of subsection (12), paragraph c. of subsection (13), paragraph c. of subsection (14), and paragraph c. of subsection (18), to read as follows: Sec. 17 -4 -51. Permitted use of land and buildings. Any use of land or structure not authorized herein as a use by right or use by review upon issuance of a special use permit in a designated zone district is unlawful. Except as otherwise provided, no building permit or certificate of zoning compliance shall be issued for a use not specifically mentioned or described in this Section and not specifically provided with the required off - street loading and parking spaces and access driveway. In the case of a proposal for a use not specifically mentioned, the Administrative Official shall request that the Planning and Zoning Commission initiate proceedings to cause the amendment of this Section to make provision for such use. (1) Agricultural One (A -1) and Two (A -2) Districts. C. Uses by review. A use by review is any of the following uses which are permitted only upon issuance of a special use permit. 1. Agricultural custom contractors. 2. Airport, private. 3. Bed and breakfast inn. 4. Cemetery, crematory, mausoleum. 5. Charitable institution. 6. Child care center and play school. 7. Explosives, manufacture and wholesale. 'a 8. Feed and fertilizer -- manufacturing and processing. 9. Feed lot. 10. Garbage and refuse dumps. 11. Hay, grain, feed, seed and fertilizer, retail, storage and /or wholesale. 12. Hide and tallow processing. 13. Home for children, blind, elderly, maternity, memorial, religious. 14. Livestock sales and auction. 15. Monastery. 16. Natural deposits, extraction and processing. 17. Preschool facilities. 17.1 Tower (Antenna) 18. Utilities as outlined in Section 17 -4 -30. (11.1) Highway and Arterial Business District (B -3): C. Uses by review. A use by review is any of the following uses which are permitted only upon issuance of a special use permit: 1. Bulk storage, warehousing or wholesaling. 1.1 Community correctional facility or program. 1.2 Homeless shelter. 2. Private recreation and amusement facilities. 3. Mobile home sales. 4. Tower (Antenna) (12) Regional Business District (B -4): C. Uses by review. A use by review is any of the following uses which are permitted only upon issuance of a special use permit. 1. Apartments, row houses, etc. 2. Bulk storage, warehousing or wholesaling. 2.1. Community correctional facility or program. -5- 2.2. Homeless shelter. 3. Private recreation and amusement facilities. 4. Tower (Antenna) (13) Special Industrial District (I -1): C. Uses by review. A use by review is any of the following uses which are permitted only upon issuance of a special use permit. 1. Aircraft beacon, marker or tower. 2. Airport, private. 3. Associations, clubs and lodges. 4. Athletic field. 5. Atomic reactor and /or similar scientific installations. 6. Charitable institutions. 7. Farming or ranching. 8. Natural deposits, extraction and /or processing. 9. Residence for watchman or caretaker. 10. Restaurant. 11. Tower (Antenna) (14) Light Industrial District (I -2): C. Uses by review. A use by review is any of the following uses which are permitted only upon issuance of a special use permit. 1. Aircraft beacon, marker or tower. 2. Airport, private. 3. Associations, clubs and lodges. 4. Atomic reactor and /or similar scientific installations. 5. Cafe, cocktail lounge, cafeteria. 6. Carnival (temporary). 7. Charitable institution. 8. Circus grounds. 9. Farming and ranching. In 10. Natural deposits, extraction. 11. Residence for watchman or caretaker. 12. Restaurant. 13. Salvage yard. 14. Sand and gravel, processing. 14.1. Solid wastes transfer station. 15. Tavern. 16. Tent show (temporary). 17. Tower (Antenna). 18 . All uses by right and uses by review permitted in the I -1 District. SECTION 5 Chapter 4, Title XVH of the Pueblo Municipal Code, as amended, is amended by the addition of a new Article VI, Towers and Antenna Requirements, to read as follows: Article VI Tower and Antenna Requirements Sec. 17 -4 -61. Applicability: purpose and goals. La, All new towers or antennas within the City shall be subject to these requirements except as provided in subsections (b) through _(d) of this Section. ,(W This Article VI shall not govern any tower, or the installation of any antenna that is under seventy (70) feet in height and is either owned and operated by a federally- licensed amateur radio station operator or is used exclusively as receive only antennas. Uc� Preexisting towers and preexisting antennas shall not be required to meet the requirements of this Article_ other than the requirements of Section 17- 4- 62(f) and (a) and Section 17 -4 -67. W For purposes of implementing this Article, an AM array, consisting of one or more tower units and supporting or u�nd system which functions as one AM broadcasting antenna shall be considered one tower. Measurements for setbacks and separation distances shall be measured from the outer perimeter of the towers included in the AM array. Additional tower units may be added within the perimeter of the AM array y right. Ue.) The purpose of this Ordinance is to establish eng eral guidelines for the siting of wireless communications towers and antennas. The goals of this Ordinance are to: (1) -7- protect residential areas and land uses from potential adverse impacts of towers and antennas: (2) encourage the location of towers in non - residential areas: (3) minimize the total number of towers throughout the community; (4 strongly encourage the joint use of new and existing tower sites as a rp imary option rather than construction of additional single -use towers (5) encourage users of towers and antennas to locate them to the extent possible, in areas where the adverse impact on the community is minimal: (6) encourage users of towers and antennas to configure them in a way that minimizes the adverse visual impact of the towers and antennas through careful design. siting. landscape screening, and innovative camouflaging techniques: (7) enhance the ability of the providers of telecommunications services to provide such services to the community quickly, effectively, and efficientI : (8) consider the public health and safety of communication towers: and 9) avoid potential dama eg_ to adjacent properties from tower failure through engineering and careful siting of tower structures In furtherance of these goals the Zoning Administrator and Zoning Board of Appeals shall give due consideration to the City's master lean, zoning map existing land uses, and environ- mentally sensitive areas in approving sites for the location of towers and antennas. Sec. 17 -4 -62. General requirements. Lai� Principal or Accessory Use. Antennas and towers may be considered either principal or accessory uses. A different existing use of an existing structure on the same lot shall not preclude the installation of an antenna or tower on such lot. W Lot Size. For purposes of determining whether the installation of a tower or antenna complies with district development regulations. including but not limited to setback requirements. lot- coverage requirements, and other such requirements the dimensions of the entire lot shall control, even though the antennas or towers may be located on leased parcels within such lot. ,Lc). Inventory of Existing Sites. Each applicant for an antenna and /or tower shall provide to the Zoning Administrator an inventory of its existing towers, antennas or sites approved for towers or antennas, that are within the City and within three miles of the corporate boundary thereof, including specific information about the location height and design of each tower, The Zoning Administrator may share such information with other applicants applying for administrative approvals or special use permits under this Article or other organizations seeking to locate antennas within the City: provided, however that the Zoning Administrator is not, by sharing such information. in any way representing or warranting that such sites are available or suitable. W Aesthetics. Towers and antennas shall meet the following requirements: W Towers shall either maintain a galvanized steel finish or, subject to any applicable standards of the FAA, be painted a neutral color so as to reduce visual obtrusiveness. In (4 At a tower site. the design of the buildings and related structures shall, to the extent possible, use materials. colors. textures. screening, and landscaping that will blend them into the natural setting and surrounding buildings. W If an antenna is installed on a structure other than a tower, the antenna and supporting electrical and mechanical equipment must be of a color that is identical to or closely compatible with. the color of the supporting structure so as to make the antenna and related equipment as visually unobtrusive as possible. U Lighting. Towers shall not be artificially lighted, unless required by the FAA or other applicable authority. If lighting grequired. the lighting alternatives and design chosen must cause the least disturbance to the surrounding views and neighborhoods. (f State or Federal Requirements. All towers must meet or exceed current standards and regulations of the FAA. the FCC, and any other agency of the state or federal government with the authority to regulate towers and antennas. If such standards and regulations are changed. then the owners of the towers and antennas governed by this Ordinance shall bring such towers and antennas into compliance with such revised standards and regulations within six (6) months of the effective date of such standards and regulations. unless a different compliance schedule is mandated by the controlling state or federal agency. Failure to bring towers and antennas into compliance with such revised standards and regulations shall constitute grounds for the removal of the tower or antenna by the City at the owner's expense. W Building; Safety Standards. To ensure the structural integrity of towers, the owner of a tower shall ensure that it is erected and maintained in compliance with standards contained in applicable state and local building codes and the applicable standards for towers that are published by the Electronic Industries Association. as amended from time to time. If. upon inspection. the City concludes that a tower fails to comply with such codes and standards and constitutes a danger to persons or propeM. then upon notice being provided to the owner of the tower. the owner shall have thirty (30) days to bring such tower into compliance with such standards. Failure to bring such tower into compliance within said thirty (30) days shall constitute grounds for the removal of the tower or antenna at the owner's expense. Measurement. For purposes of measurement, tower setbacks and separation distances shall be calculated and applied to facilities located within the City irrespective of municipal and county jurisdictional boundaries. Other Approvals. To the extent applicable. owners and /or operators of towers or antennas for telecommunication purposes shall certify that necessary authorization from the FCC and the Colorado Public Utilities Commission for operation of a wireless communications system in Pueblo has been obtained and file a copy of all such authorizations with the Zoning Administrator In fD In the event the owners and /or operators of any towers or antennas use or intend to use a backhaul network in connection with such towers or antennas that involve placement of lines, wire, fiber, conduit or other facilities within the public rights of way of he City such owner or operator shall first have obtained either a duly authorized franchise or written consent of the City to do so. This requirement shall not apply to the extent an owner or operator's backhaul network involves only the use of lines, wire, fiber, conduit or other facilities owned by a third party telecommunications provider or cable television provider which has previously been granted a franchise or received such consent with respect to such lines, wire, fiber. conduit or other facilities. W Public Notice. For purposes of this Ordinance, any special use request, variance request. or appeal of an administratively approved use or special use shall require public notice to all abutting_propertv owners and all gropertv owners of properties that are located within the corresponding separation distance listed in Section 17- 4- 65(b)(5)(ii), Table 2. in addition to any notice otherwise required by the Zoning Ordinance. In order to effectuate this subsection (k). Applicant shall furnish with the application or appeal, a list of names and addresses of all owners of land within said separation distances, which list shall be certified as being correct according to the records of the County Clerk and Recorder. Signs. No signs shall be allowed on an antenna or tower, except for required or appropriate signs located not more than 6 feet above ground level warning of hi hg voltage or other hazards. Lm) Buildings and Support Equipment. Buildings and sunnort equipment associated with antennas or towers shall comply with the requirements of Section 17 -4 -66. Un Multiple Antenna/Tower Plan. The City encourages the users of towers and antennas to submit a single application for approval of multiple towers and /or antenna sites. Applications for approval of multiple sites shall be ig ven priority in the review process. See. 17 -4 -63. Permitted uses. W General. The uses listed in this Section are deemed to be permitted uses and shall not require administrative approval or a special use permit. Permitted Uses. The following uses are specifically permitted: W Antennas or towers located on property owned. leased. or otherwise controlled by City provided a lease consistent with the purpose and goals of Section 17 -4 -61 of this Chapter authorizing, such antenna or tower has been approved by City Council. Nothing in this subsection (b)(1), however. shall be construed to reauire anv such lease. the granting or denial of same being within the discretion of the City Council. -10- (22) Antennas or towers located in an I -3 Zone District, provided the location is not less than 1.000 feet from any residentially zoned property. Sec. 17 -4 -64. Administrative approval of certain uses. La) General. The following_ provisions shall szovern the issuance of administrative approvals for towers and antennas. W The Zoning Administrator may administratively approve the uses listed in this Section. Each applicant for administrative approval shall apply to the Zoning Administrator providing the information set forth in Sections 17- 4- 65(b)(1) and 17-4 - 65(b)((3) of this Article and a nonrefundable fee as established by resolution of the City Council to reimburse City for the costs of reviewing the he application. W The Zoning Administrator shall review the application for administrative approval and determine if the proposed use compfies with Sections 17 -4 -62 and 17-4 - 65(b)(4) and 17- 4- 65(b )(5) of this Title. W The Zoning Administrator shall respond to each such application within sixty (60) days after receiving it by either approving g_ r denying �pplication. If the Zoning Administrator fails to respond to the appficant within said sixty (60) days, then the application shall be deemed to be denied. W In connection with any such administrative approval. the Zoning Administrator may, in order to encourage shared use. administratively waive an y z_ oning district setback requirements in Section 17- 4- 65(b)(4 or separation distances between towers in Section 17- 4- 65(b)(5) by up to fifty percent (,50 %). (o In connection with any such administrative approval. the Zoning Administrator may, in order to encourage the use of monopoles. administratively allow the reconstruction of an existing tower to monopole construction. If an administrative approval is denied or deemed to be denied, the applicant shall file an application for a special use permit pursuant to Section 17 -4 -65 prior to filing any appeal that may be available under the Zoning Ordinance. List of Administratively Approved Uses The following uses maybe approved by the Zoning Administrator after conducting an administrative review: W Locating a tower or antenna including the placement of additional buildings or other supporting equipment used in connection with said tower or antenna, in any -11- I -3 or S -3 zone district. (Z Locating antennas on existing structures or towers consistent with the terms of subsections (A) and (B) below. Antennas on existing structures. Any antenna which is not attached to a tower may be approved by the Zoning Administrator as an accessory use to any commercial, industrial, professional, institutional. or multi - family structure of eight or more dwelling units provided: Q The antenna does not extend more than thirty (30) feet above the highest point of the structure: ii The antenna complies with all applicable FCC and FAA regulations: and iii The antenna complies with all applicable building odes. Antennas on existing towers. An antenna which is attached to an existing tower may be approved by the Zoning Administrator and, to minimize adverse visual impacts associated with the proliferation and clustering of towers. collocation of antennas by more than one carrier on existing towers shall take precedence over the construction of new towers, provided such collocation is accomplished in a manner consistent with the following_ to A tower which is modified or reconstructed to accommodate the collocation of an additional antenna shall be of the same tower type as the existing tower, unless the Zoning Administrator allows reconstruction as a monopole. ii Height An existing tower may be modified or rebuilt to a taller height, not to exceed thirty (30) feet over the tower's existing height_ to accommodate the collocation of an additional antenna. II The height change referred to in paragraph (ii)(I above may only occur one time per communication tower. III The additional height referred to in paragraph (ii)(I) above shall not require an additional distance -12- separation as set forth in Section 17 -4 -65. The tower's premodification height shall be used to calculate such distance separations. iii Onsite location A tower which is being rebuilt to accommodate the collocation of an additional antenna may be moved onsite within fifty (50) feet of its existing location. II After the tower is rebuilt to accommodate collocation only one tower may remain on the site. III A relocated onsite tower shall continue to be measured from the original tower location for purposes of calculating separation distances between towers pursuant to Section 17- 4- 65(b)(5). The relocation of a tower hereunder shall in no way be deemed to cause a violation of Section 17- 4- 65(b)(5). IV The onsite relocation of a tower which comes within the separation distances to residential units or residentially zoned lands as established in Section 17- 4- 65(b)(5) shall only be permitted when approved by the Zoning, Administrator, W Locating any new tower in an A -1, A -2. B -3. B-4. I -1 or I -2 zoning district, provided a licensed professional engineer certifies the tower can structurally accommodate the number of shared users proposed by the applicant: the Zoning Administrator concludes the tower is in conformity with the goals set forth in Section 17 -4 -61 and the requirements of Section 17 -4 -62; the tower meets the setback requirements in Section 17- 4- 65(b)(4) and separation distances in Section 17-4 - 65(b)(5)_ and the tower meets the following height and usage criteria: LA for a single user .up to eighty (80) feet in height for two users. up to one hundred ten (110) feet in height, , and Q for three or more users, up to one hundred thirty (130) feet in height. W Locating any alternative tower structure in an A -1 A -2 B -3 B -4 I -1 or I -2 zoning district that in the judgment of the Zoning Administrator is in conformity with the goals set forth in Section 17 -4 -61 of this Ordinance. -13- Installing a cable microcell network through the use of multiple low - powered transmitters /receivers attached to existing wireline s sy tems_ such as conventional cable or telephone wires, or similar technology that does not require the use of towers. Sec. 17 -4 -65, Special Use Permits. Ua� The following additional provisions shall govern the issuance of special use permits for towers or antennas by the Zoning Board of Appeals: W If the tower or antenna is not a permitted use under Section 17 -4 -63 of this Chapter or permitted to be approved administratively pursuant to Section 17 -4 -64 of this Chapter, then a special use permit shall be required for the construction of a tower or the placement of an ant enna in all zoning districts where allowed as a use by review. W Applications for special use permits under this Section shall be subject to the procedures and requirements of Section 17 -5 -33 of Chapter 5 of this Title, except as modified by this Section. W In rg anting a special use permit. the Zoning Board of Appeals may impose reasonable conditions to the extent the Zoning Board of Appeals concludes such conditions are necessary to minimize any adverse effect of the proposed tower on adjoining properties. W Any information of an engineering nature that the applicant submits, whether civil, mechanical. or electrical_ shall be certified by a licensed professional engineer. W An applicant for a special use permit shall submit the information described in this Section and a non - refundable fee as established by resolution of the City Council to reimburse City for the costs of reviewing �pplication. (W Towers. W Information required. In addition to any information required for applications for special use permits pursuant to Section 17 -5 -33 of Chapter 5 of this Title, appficants for a special use permit for a tower shall submit the following information: A scaled site plan clearly indicating the location, type and height of the proposed tower on -site land uses and zoning, adjacent land uses and zoning Master Plan classification of the site and all properties within the applicable separation distances set forth in subsection (b)(5) of this Section. adjacent roadway proposed means of access setbacks from propert lam_ elevation drawings of the proposed tower and any other structures. topography, parkins and other information deemed by the Zoning Administrator to be -14- necessary to assess compliance with this Article VI. Legal description of the parent tract and leased parcel (if applicable). The setback distance between the proposed tower and the nearest residential unit, platted residentially zoned properties. and unplatted residentially zoned properties. Q The separation distance from other towers described in the inventory of existing sites submitted pursuant to Section 17- 4- 62(c shall be shown on an updated site plan or man. The applicant shall also identify the type of construction of the existing ower(s) and the owner /operator of the existing tower (s). if known. A landscape plan showing specific landscape materials in accordance with the requirements of this Chapter or the requirements of Section 17 -4 -7, whichever requirements are rem Method of fencing and finished color and if applicable, the method of camouflasie and illumination. j A descriptive statement indicating compliance with Section 17-4 - 62(c). (d). (e). (f). (g). (j) (D. and (m). and subsections (b)(4) and (b)(5) of this Section and all applicable federal, state and local laws. (W A notarized statement by the applicant as to whether construction of the tower will accommodate collocation of additional antennas for future users. (a Identification of the entities rop viding the backhaul network for the tower(s) described in the application and other cellular sites owned or operated b, the he applicant within the City. (I A description of the suitability of the use of existing towers. other structures or alternative technology not requiring the use of towers or structures to provide the services to be provided through the use of the proposed new tower. A description of the feasible location(s) of future towers or antennas within the City based upon existing_ physical. engineering. technological or geographical limitations in the event the proposed tower is erected. Q Factors Considered in Granting Special Use Permits for Towers. In addition -15- to any standards for consideration of special use permit applications pursuant to Section 17 -5 -33 of Chapter 5 of this Title. the Zoning Board of Appeals shall consider the following factors in determining whether to issue a special use permit, although the Zoning Board of Appeals may waive or reduce the burden on the applicant of one or more of these criteria if the Zoning Board of Appeals concludes that the goa „ this Ordinance are better served thereby; LA,� Height of the proposed tower: Proximity of the tower to residential structures and residential district boundaries: (Q Nature of uses on adjacent and nearby properties: Surrounding topography: LEA Surrounding tree coverage and foliage: Design of the tower, with particular reference to design characteristics that have the effect of reducing or eliminating visual obtrusiveness: LG Proposed ingress and egress; and Availability of suitable existing g owers, other structures, or alternative technologies not requiring the use of towers or structures, as discussed in subsection (b)(3) of this Section. W Availability of Suitable Existing Towers. Other Structures. or Alternative Technology. No new tower shall be permitted unless the applicant demonstrates to the reasonable satisfaction of the Zoning Board of Appeals that no existing tower, ower• structure or alternative technology that does not require the use of towers or structures can accommodate the applicant's a proposed antenna. An applicant shall submit information requested by the Zoning Board of Appeals related to the availability of suitable existing towers, other structures or alternative technology. Evidence submitted to demonstrate that no existing tower, ower. structure or alternative technology can accommodate the applicant's proposed antenna may consist of proof of anv of the following: No existing towers or structures are located within the geographic area which meet applicant's engineering requirements. Existing towers or structures are not of sufficient height to meet applicant's engineering �� requirements. -16- Existing towers or structures do not have sufficient structural strength to support applicant's proposed antenna and related equipment. The applicant's proposed antenna would cause electromagnetic interference with the antenna on the existing towers or structures, or the antenna on the existing towers or structures would cause interference with the applicant's proposed antenna. The fees, costs, or contractual provisions required by the owner in order to share an existing tower or structure or to adapt an existing tower or structure for sharing are unreasonable. Costs exceeding new tower develop- ment are presumed to be unreasonable. M The applicant demonstrates that there are other limiting factors that render existing towers and structures unsuitable. U The applicant demonstrates that an alternative technology that does not require the use of towers or structures, such as a cable microcell network using multiple low- powered transmitters /receivers attached to a wireline system, is unsuitable. Costs of alternative technology that exceed new tower or antenna development shall not be presumed to render the technology unsuitable. Setbacks. The following setback requirements shall apply to all towers for which a special use permit is required, provided, however, that the Zoning Board of Appeals may reduce the standard setback requirements if the goals of this Article VI would be better served thereby Towers must be set back a distance equal to at least seventy -five percent (75 %) of the height of the tower from any adjoining lot line. Guys and accessory buildings must satisfy the minimum zoning district setback requirements. Separation. The following separation requirements shall apply to all towers and antennas for which a special use permit is required, provided, however, that the Zoning Board of Appeals may reduce the standard separation requirements if the goals of this Article would be better served thereby. Separation from off -site uses /designated areas. 10 Tower separation shall be measured from the base of the tower to the lot line of the off -site uses and /or desi ng ated areas as specified in Table I. except as otherwise provided in -17- Rev. 8123199 Table 1. ii Separation requirements for towers shall comply with the minimum standards established in Table 1. iii Table 1: Off -site Use/Designated Area Separation Distance Single- family or duplex residential units l 500 feet or 300% height of tower whichever is greater Vacant single - family or duplex residentially 500 feet or 300% height of tower whichever zoned land which is either platted or has is greater preliminary subdivision plan approval which is not expired Vacant unplatted residentially zoned lands 200 feet or 200% height of tower whichever is greater Existing multi - family residential units greater 100 feet or 100% height of tower whichever than duplex units is greater Non - residentially zoned lands or non- None; only setbacks apply residential uses I Includes modular homes and mobile homes used for living purposes. 2 Separation measured from base of tower to closest building setback line. 3 Includes any unplatted residential use properties without a valid preliminary subdivision plan or valid development plan approval and any multi - family residentially zoned land greater than duplex. (W Separation distances between towers. U Separation distances between towers shall be applicable for and measured between the rrooposed tower and preexisting towers. The separation distances shall be measured by drawing or following a straight line between the base of the existing tower and the proposed base. pursuant to a site plan. of the proposed tower, The separation distances (listed in linear feet) shall be as shown in Table 2. -18- ii Table 2: Existing Towers - Types Security fencing. Towers shall be enclosed by security fencing not less than six feet in height and shall also be equipped with an appropriate anti-climbing evice: provided however that the Zoning Board of Appeals may waive such requirements, as it deems appropriate. Landscaping. The following requirements shall govern the landscaping surrounding towers for which a special use permit is required: provided however that the Zoning Board of Appeals may waive such requirements if the goals of this Ordinance would be better served thereb Tower facilities shall be landscaped with a buffer of plant materials that effectively screens the view of the tower compound from property used for residences. The standard buffer shall consist of a landscaped strip at least four (4) feet wide outside the perimeter of the compound. In locations where the visual impact of the tower would be minimal. the landscaping requirement may be reduced or waived. Existing mature tree growth and natural land forms on the site shall be preserved to the maximum extent possible. In some cases, such as towers sited on large_ wooded lots. natural growth around the property perimeter may be sufficient buffer. -19- Lattice Guyed Monopole 75 Ft. Monopole Less in Height or Than 75 Ft. in Greater Height Lattice 5,000 5,000 1,500 750 Guyed 5,000 5,000 1,500 750 Monopole 75 Ft. 1,500 1,500 1,500 750 in Height or Greater Monopole Less 750 750 750 750 Thank 75 Ft. in Height Security fencing. Towers shall be enclosed by security fencing not less than six feet in height and shall also be equipped with an appropriate anti-climbing evice: provided however that the Zoning Board of Appeals may waive such requirements, as it deems appropriate. Landscaping. The following requirements shall govern the landscaping surrounding towers for which a special use permit is required: provided however that the Zoning Board of Appeals may waive such requirements if the goals of this Ordinance would be better served thereb Tower facilities shall be landscaped with a buffer of plant materials that effectively screens the view of the tower compound from property used for residences. The standard buffer shall consist of a landscaped strip at least four (4) feet wide outside the perimeter of the compound. In locations where the visual impact of the tower would be minimal. the landscaping requirement may be reduced or waived. Existing mature tree growth and natural land forms on the site shall be preserved to the maximum extent possible. In some cases, such as towers sited on large_ wooded lots. natural growth around the property perimeter may be sufficient buffer. -19- See. 17 -4 -66: Buildings or other eauinment storage. j Equipment cabinets or uninhabited structures used in association with antennas shall comply with all provisions of this Title applicable to accessory buildings. and comply with all applicable building g odes. (b2 Antennas Mounted on Utility Poles or Light Poles. The equipment cabinet or structure used in association with antennas mounted on utilitYpoles or light poles shall be located in accordance with the following_ W In residential districts (where allowed), the equipment cabinet or structure may be located: In a front or side yard provided the cabinet or structure is no rg eater than 4 feet in height and 36 square feet of gross floor area and the cabinet /structure is located a minimum of 10 feet from all lot lines. The cabinet /structure shall be screened by an evergreen hedge with an ultimate height of at least 48 inches and a planted height of at least 36 inches. CW In a rear yard, provided the cabinet or structure is no greater than 6 feet in height or 72 square feet in gross floor area. The cabinet /structure shall be screened by an evergreen hedge with an ultimate height ght (8) feet and a planted height of at least 36 inches. W In commercial districts the equipment cabinet or structure shall be no greater than 12 feet in height or 120 square feet in gross floor area. The structure or cabinet shall be screened by an evergreen hedge with an ultimate height ght (8) feet and a planted height of at least 36 inches. In all other instances, structures or cabinets shall be screened from view of all residential properties which abut or are directly across the street from the structure or cabinet by a solid fence 8 feet in height or an evergreen hedge with an ultimate height of eight (8) feet and a planted height of at least 36 inches. U Antennas Located on Towers. The related unmanned equipment structure shall not contain more than 200 square feet of gross floor area or be more than 15 feet in height and shall be located in accordance with the minimum yard requirements of the zoning district in which located. (M Modification of Building Size Requirements. The requirements of subsections (a) through (c) may be modified by the Zoning Administrator in the case of administratively approved uses or by the Zoning Board of Appeals in the case of uses permitted by special use in order to encourage collocation. -20- Sec. 17 -4 -67. Removal of Abandoned Antennas and Towers. Any antenna or tower that is not operated for a continuous period of twelve (12) months shall be considered abandoned. and the owner of such antenna or tower shall remove the same within ninety (90) days of receipt of notice from the Zoning Administrator notifying the owner of such abandonment. Failure to remove an abandoned antenna or tower within said ninety (90) day shall be grounds for the City to remove the tower or antenna at the owner's expense If there are two or more users of a single tower. then this provision shall not become effective until all users cease using the tower. Sec. 17 -4 -68, Nonconforming Uses. Ua) Not Expansion of Nonconforming Use Towers that are constructed. and antennas that are installed in accordance with the provisions of this Article VI shall not be deemed to constitute the expansion of a nonconforming, use or structure. W Preexisting towers Preexisting towers shall be allowed to continue their usage as thgy_presently exist Routine maintenance (including replacement with a new tower of like construction and height) shall be permitted on such preexisting towers. New construction other than routine maintenance on a preexisting tower shall comply with the requirements of this Article. (-c� Rebuilding Damaged or Destroyed Nonconforming_ Towers or Antennas. Notwith- standing Section 17 -4 -67 bona fide nonconforming towers or antennas that are damp eg d or destroyed may be rebuilt without having to first obtain administrative approval or a special use permit and without having to meet the separation requirements specified in Sections 17-4 - 65(b)(4_,,Td O(5) The type height and location of the tower onsite shall be of the same We and intensity as the original facilily approval Building hermits to rebuild the facility shall co=ny with the then applicable building codes and shall be obtained within 180 days from the date the facility is damaged or destroyed If no permit is obtained or if said permit Mires, the tower or antenna shall be deemed abandoned as specified in Section 17 -4 -67. Sec. 17 -4 -69. Severabilitv. The various parts sections and clauses of this Article III are hereby declared to be severable. If any part sentence Para rg anh section or clause is adjudged unconstitutional or invalid by a court of competent jurisdiction the remainder of the Article shall not be affected thereby. SECTION 6 This Ordinance shall become effective thirty (30) days after final passage and approval. -21- ATTEST: ,,, P- City II& INTRODUCED: August 9 By John Verna Councilperson APP D: President of the City Council -22- 1999 Minutes of the Special & Regular P &Z Meeting Page three July 14, 1999 the storm water to flow south to Oakshire Lane which is away from Mr. Lopez's property. Rich Morgan then further explained how the drainage would be handled for this property. He noted that the drainage plans are calculated on the historic and developed flow. Greg Hahn, owner of property in the 1900 block Salem, said this part of the City has been very active for development. Some of the development has been put in an unattractive situation as they face the rear of the buildings to the street. This is an esthetic issue the City should address. Mr. Perez appeared again and said the storm water will be detained and then released at the historic rate. The swale will be between the structure and the property line. No one else appeared to be heard on either the plat or the special area plan. Chairman Lytle made the staff report a part of the record and closed the hearing. 5. Ordinance Amendment: An ordinance amending Title XVII of the City of Pueblo Code of Ordinances relating to telecommunica- tions towers and antennas, permitted locations therefor, performance standards therefor, and special use permits therefor - (City of Pueblo). Paul Willumstad presented the proposedamendment to the Commission. He said it is in response to an increase in requestsfor variances for cellular towers. The proposed ordinance is a national ordinance that has been modified to local ordinances. It addresses some concerns of neighborhoods such as not having too many in one neighbor- hood. The ordinance will require landscaping and fencing. All towers in any zone district allowing them will need to obtain a special use permit the Zoning Board of Appeals. Mr. Willumstad said the proposed regulations are lengthy and thorough. This amendment is needed before there is a prolification of cellular towers in the City. No one else appeared to speak to this amendment. Chair- man Lytle then closed-the hearing. SUMMARY OF PROPOSED TELECOMMUNICATIONS TOWERS AND ANTENNAS ORDINANCE The proposed ordinance is designed as a comprehensive regulatory approach to provide for the review and approval of applications for towers and antennas for PCS, cellular, telephone, radio, and similar wireless telecommunications signals or other communications signals. The ordinance is based on a model ordinance adopted by other communities which is designed to encourage the location of towers and antennas on municipally owned property and property zoned industrial or commercial. Incentives are provided to encourage users of antennas and towers to collocate such facilities. The goals of the ordinance include protecting residential areas and land uses from the potential adverse impacts of towers and antennas and minimizing the total number of towers throughout the community. A brief summary of the key concepts contained in the ordinance is presented below. It is important that the City adopt an ordinance of this nature, either now or in the immediate future, in order to avoid the potential irreversible placement of towers which are or may be inconsistent with present and planned land use within the City. Integration With Existing Zoning Ordinance The proposed ordinance is drafted in a manner to integrate with Pueblo's existing zoning ordinance. A conscious effort was made not to disturb the scheme of the existing zoning ordinance which represents City Council's zoning policies. For convenience, the references in this memorandum are to the codified sections of the Pueblo Municipal Code ( "PMC "). As a starting point, PMC Sec. 17 -4 -51 is amended to permit new towers as a use by right (subject to certain separation requirements) only where presently so allowed (I -3), and as a "use by review" in A -1, A -2, B -3, B -4, 1- 1, and I -2 zones, subject to and in accordance with the requirements of the ordinance. Towers are also currently allowed as a use by review in S -3 districts, and that status has been continued. Definitions The ordinance adds or amends definitions of key terms set forth in PMC Sec. 17 -2 -1. Included are definitions of "alternative tower structures ", referring to towers designed to look like manmade trees, clock towers, etc. Also included is a definition for the term "backhaul network ", referring to the land based lines that connect a provider's towers /cell sites to one or more cellular telephone switching offices and /or long distance providers. Information regarding an applicant's backhaul network is helpful to the City to determine if requisite licences to use public rights of way (such as those recently obtained by ICG Telecom and McLeod USA) have been obtained as consent to use of the City's streets in the provision of telecommunication services. In particular, tower applicants are required to disclose whose wires will connect their antennas together, or to a phone system, so that the City can evaluate whether the entity owning the wires needs a license. It is important that all telecommunications providers using the rights of way be licensed and required to pay the City's occupation taxes in the same manner, or such regulations and taxes may be at risk under antidiscrimination provisions of the 1996 Telecommunications Act or provisions in Colorado's Senate Bill 96 -10. Preexisting towers are defined in order to include "grand fathering provisions" that respect property rights already in existence. An amendment to PMC Sec. 17 -4 -30 is made to clarify that neither wireless providers nor their towers are to be considered "utilities" within the meaning of the zoning ordinance, since many utility facilities (gas lines, electrical conduits, etc.) are allowed throughout the City, regardless of zone district. Goals and Purpose Proposed section 17 -4 -61 states the applicability, goals and purpose of the ordinance. This section indicates an intent to protect residential areas from adverse impacts, minimize the number of towers in the community, encourage co- location, minimize visual impacts, and enhance providers of telecommunication services ability to provide such services. In furtherance of these goals, consideration is to be given of the master plan, existing land uses, and the environment in approving sites for the location of towers and antennas. It is the intent of the ordinance to encourage owners of towers and antennas to locate them in areas where they will not adversely affect existing or planned land uses. Applicability The ordinance applies to all towers or antennas constructed or erected after the effective date of the ordinance, with certain exceptions. The ordinance does not apply to towers or antennas under 70 feet in height that are owned and operated by a federally licensed amateur radio station operator or used exclusively for receive only antennas. Preexisting towers or preexisting antennas are required to comply only with state or federal requirements and applicable building code and safety standards described in the ordinance. Towers that are part of an AM array are also treated as one tower for purposes of application of the proposed ordinance. See 17 -4 -61. General Requirements Section 17 -4 -62 describes requirements that are generally applicable to towers or antennas. This section provides that antennas and towers may be considered either a principal or accessory use. Each applicant for an antenna and/or tower is required to provide an inventory of existing sites listing existing towers, antennas or sites approved for towers or antennas that are either within the City or within three miles of the border thereof. It is specifically stated that the information contained in inventories of existing sites may be shared with other applicants. It is the intent of the ordinance that this information will be -2- shared in order to encourage collocation. This section also describes standards for aesthetics, lighting, compliance with state or federal requirements, compliance with building codes and safety standards, licenses or other required approvals, and compliance with building and support equipment requirements. The section also describes a method of calculating measurements. Section 17 -4 -62 requires that public notice of any special use request, variance request, or appeal of an administratively approved special use shall be given to all abutting property owners and all property owners within the separation distances described in the ordinance. This section prohibits signs on antennas or towers except for hazard warning signs at the base. This section also encourages the users of the towers and antennas to submit a single application for approval of multiple towers and/or antenna sites. Applications for approval of multiple sites are given priority in the review process. The purpose of this provision is to recognize the physical, geographical and technological limitations on tower or antenna siting. Due to limitations of existing technology, the location of one tower or antenna' in a community may have an impact on the location of subsequent towers and antennas. By encouraging single applications for multiple towers and/or antenna sites, the City can assess the impact of the location of a single tower on the remainder of the community and, perhaps, influence the location of towers and antennas to minimize the impact on residential areas. Approval of Towers and Antennas Sections 17 -4 -63, 17 -4 -64 and 17 -4 -65 of the ordinance describe three classes of approvals for towers or antennas. Section 17 -4 -63 provides for antenna or tower uses that are permitted as of right without any administrative approval or special use permit. Section 17 -4 -64 describes those antenna and tower uses which may be approved administratively. Section 17 -4 -64 delegates that authority to the Zoning Administrator, subject to review as for other approvals by the Zoning Administrator. Section 17 -4 -65 describes those tower or antenna uses which require a special use permit, including those uses where administrative approval has been denied. The ordinance actually allows placement of an antenna or tower as of right without administrative or special use approval in only two situations. First, section 17 -4 -63 authorizes antennas or towers to be located on property owned, leased or otherwise controlled by the municipality provided a lease authorizing such antenna or tower has been approved by the City Council. It is anticipated that in negotiating a lease of publicly owned property for antennas or towers the City would already control the leasing process so as to approve towers or antennas only where deemed consistent with the goals of the ordinance, and the matter would be subject to public review before the City Council. In this situation, 992 an administrative approval or special use approval constitutes an unnecessary administrative burden. Secondly, the ordinance allows a tower /antenna in an I -3 zone as a use by right where the separation distance is 1000 feet from any residentially zoned property. Section 17 -4 -64 of the ordinance authorizes, but does not mandate, the Zoning Administrator to approve a variety of antenna or tower uses. These uses include locating a tower or antenna in any I -3 or S -3 zone district, locating antennas on existing structures or towers subject to certain height limitations, and collocating antennas on existing or new towers. It is the intent of the administratively approved use provisions to encourage placement of towers and antennas in industrial or commercial districts and to encourage collocation, thus minimizing the number of towers in the community. In order for an applicant for a new tower to avail itself of such administrative approval, the proposed tower must meet height limitations which vary depending upon the number of users. An applicant for administrative approval is required to submit information to the zoning administrator similar to that which is submitted to the Zoning Board of Appeals in the special use approval process. In order to further encourage collocation, the zoning administrator is given the authority to waive setback and separation distance requirements by up to 50 percent. The ordinance provides that the zoning administrator has 60 days in which to approve or deny the application. If the zoning administrators fails to respond within 60 days, the application is deemed to be denied. The ordinance provides that an applicant whose request for administrative approval is denied is required to file an application for a special use permit prior to filing any appeal that may be available under the zoning ordinance. Section 17 -4 -65 provides that a special use permit is required for the construction of a tower or the placement of an antenna if the tower or antenna is not permitted under section 17 -4 -63 or section 17 -4 -64. The application for a special use permit is required to comply with existing City requirements applicable to special use permits, and must include a site plan, legal description of the property, setback distances, separation distances from other towers, a landscape plan, a method of fencing, aesthetics, method of camouflage and illumination, a description of compliance with the requirements of section 17 -4 -62, a notarized statement as to whether the tower will accommodate collocation of antennas for future users, and identification of the entities providing the backhaul network for the tower. In order to encourage the use of existing towers or alternative technologies that will reduce the need for towers in the community, an applicant for a special use permit is required to submit a description of the suitability of the use of existing towers or other structures, as well as alternative technology not requiring the use of towers or structures, to provide the services to be provided through the use of the proposed new tower. Applicants are required to submit information requested by the Zoning Board of Appeals related to the availability of suitable existing towers, other structures, or alternative technology. The ordinance describes the evidence which should be submitted to demonstrate that no existing tower, C1 structure or alternative technology can accommodate the applicant's proposed antenna. An applicant for a special use permit is also required to describe the feasible locations of future towers or antennas within the municipality based upon existing physical, engineering, technological or geographical limitations. As previously indicated, the location of a single tower may have a direct impact on the feasible location of future towers and antennas. The information requested is intended to provide the City with some perspective on where future towers or antennas will have to be located if the tower which is the subject of the special use application is approved. Section 17 -4 -65 describes factors, in addition to those which may already be contained in the zoning ordinance, that are to be considered by the Zoning Board of Appeals in granting special use permits for towers. The factors to be considered are consistent with the goals set forth in section 17 -4 -61 of the ordinance. Section 17 -4 -65 establishes setback requirements for towers. Towers must be set back a distance equal to at least 75 percent of the height of the tower from any adjoining lot line. The ordinance also provides for the separation of towers from off -site uses /designated areas and separation distances between towers. The Zoning Board of Appeals is authorized to reduce the standard setback and separation requirements in order to better serve the goals of the ordinance. Finally, section 17 -4 -65 provides requirements for security fencing and landscaping, subject to modification by the ZBA in order to serve the goals of the ordinance. Buildings or Other Equipment Storage Section 17 -4 -66 provides for limits on the height or size of buildings or cabinets used to store equipment associated with antennas. The appropriate size of these buildings or cabinets will depend on a variety of factors, including available technology and local aesthetis. In general, the height and size limitations vary according to zone district, again to encourage placement in industrial /commercial zone districts, while allowing reasonably sized facilities elsewhere when it furthers the ordinance goals. Removal of Abandoned Antennas and Towers Section 17 -4 -68 provides that an antenna or tower that is not operated for a continuous period of twelve months shall be considered abandoned. The owner of an abandoned antenna or tower is required to remove the same within 90 days of receipt of notice from the Zoning Administrator notifying the owner of the abandonment. The failure to remove an abandoned antenna or tower within the specified period of time shall be grounds for the City to remove the tower or antenna at the owner's expense. Importantly, this section does apply to existing towers, without legally effecting an impairment of property rights. -5- Non - conforming Uses Section 17 -4 -68 of the ordinance provides that the addition of a tower or antenna to a property in accordance with the ordinance will not be deemed to constitute the expansion of a non - conforming use or structure. The ordinance specifically provides that pre- existing towers are allowed to continue and that routine maintenance, including replacement with a new tower of like construction and height is permitted. This section also provides that towers or antennas that are damaged or destroyed may be promptly rebuilt without having to first obtain administrative or special use approval. The type, height and location of the tower on site shall be of the same type, height and intensity as the original facility. Building permits to rebuild the facility must comply with the then applicable building codes and must be obtained within 180 days from the date the facility is damaged or destroyed. If a building permit is not obtained or if it expires, the tower or antenna is deemed abandoned as specified in section 17 -4 -67. Severabilily, Effective Date The ordinance contains standard language providing for severability of the provisions and provides that its effective date is 30 days after final passage. When the ordinance becomes effective, it will supercede the moratorium on new antennas and towers presently in effect. Model This ordinance is based upon the suggested model ordinance distributed under license by Varnum, Riddering, Schmidt & Howlett LLP, of Grand Rapids, Michigan. That law firm indicates that it has represented over 200 municipalities with respect to telecommunications issues. The independent research done by our office suggests that the approach set forth in the proposed ordinance comports with existing federal and state law as of this time. However, as telecommunications law evolves with respect to local land use issues, it may in the future be necessary to reevaluate or amend the ordinance. Son