Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout08551Reception 1937709 03/21/2013 02:52:14 pm Substituted Copy 12/05/12 ORDINANCE NO. 8551 AN ORDINANCE DESIGNATING THE NORTH SIDE LOCAL alE HISTORIC DISTRICT, PHASE II z WHEREAS, the City of Pueblo's Historic Preservation Code, Title IV, Chapter 14, declares that the City Council may identify, designate, and preserve those buildings, objects, monuments, structures, and sites which reflect outstanding elements of the N a community's architectural and cultural heritage; and N a M 1 WHEREAS, an application was submitted by the Old Northside Neighborhood N Organization, and the City's Historic Preservation Commission has reviewed the application for designation as a Local Historic District and has recommended approval tit to the Planning and Zoning Commission the designation of this district; and o il WHEREAS, the motion to recommend approval of the proposed district by the ea Planning and Zoning Commission failed by a vote of 2 to 3 without explanation; NOW, P i =_- THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF PUEBLO, that: SECTION 1. The City Council finds and determines that the North Side Local Historic District, Mh.rN Phase II, Pueblo, Colorado, bounded by West Street east to Main and 19 Street north to 20 street as shown on attached Exhibit "A" and legally described as 0 U a Ferd Barndollar and Co's Addition, #2, Blocks 12 and 21, Lots 1 -32 (all inclusive), ate Dundee Place, Blocks 21, 22, & 23, Lots 1 -32 (all inclusive), and Ragle's Subdivision, m Lots 1 -13, has significant character, interest or value, as part of the development, mma MOD heritage, or cultural characteristics of the City, and embodies those distinguishing (1,-� NMY M� m� characteristics of an architectural type or engineering specimen, as defined in the m oo" Pueblo Historic Preservation Code Section 4 -14 -8. EN O pvm� SECTION 2. The City Council hereby designates the area described in Section 1 as the North Side Local Historic District, Phase II, subject to the benefits, obligations, and restrictions resulting from such designation as described in Title IV, Chapter 14 of the Pueblo Municipal Code. Substituted Copy 12/05/12 SECTION 3. Of the 84 properties surveyed in Phase II, 78 are eligible for designation as part of the North Side Historic District, Phase II and six properties were determined to be non- contributing. All 84 homeowners may be excluded or OPT OUT, by signing a certified letter mailed from the Director of Planning and Community Development to the owner on record. The OPT OUT letter must be signed and notarized by the property owner on record and returned to the Director of Planning and Community Development a O by February 11, 2013. All Property Owners that do not timely OPT OUT of the District i ; by February 11, 2013 shall be included in the master list called Exhibit B, "North Side : HE m — Historic District Phase II Final Property List." 2 Y� SECTION 4. o �y This Ordinance shall become effective on February 11, 2013 . A certified copy of co w ' this Ordinance, together with attached Exhibits "A" and "B" shall be recorded in the m° f� I records of the Pueblo County Clerk and Recorder by the City Clerk concerning all properties in Exhibit "B ". In addition, the City shall send by certified mail, return receipt requested, a copy of the Ordinance to all property owners in Phase II of the Historic District within fourteen days of the passage of this Ordinance. 4 4, x ,Q o ., INTRODUCED: November 26, 2012 a � o /467, f,� ! i Ij t p { ' , c BY: Leroy Garcia 6, 44 C • N CI RS N '` a ~ m crl 40/ APPROVED: / P" ESI r O' CITY COUNCIL m°f m g ATTESTED = ",'4' j'..°9-.%41: � o U CITY CLERK 01 r) 0 r IL PASSED AND APPROVED: December 10, 2012 M_ ---- -I r -`''' . •-• 4 - ' . • - . ' - - ' ,,,-, , , --'- ' ..- , ' 1 ir 1 II ; - , -.t. ... , IP • Fs tel. , id - •tt.4 .4j A " 54i .. : 1936238 ORD 03/08/2013 02:52:14 PM ' ,, : - '''''. ,, •-- ' , 4 . Pa:e: 4 of 5 R 31.00 D 0 ', - .. - ` • - • .r.er, Pueblo County, Co .. g t ti,.. 11111 1111 r. 6 pri i iimorwiilillNiLli a lelH.Liq lilfil - ' 41 4 - . me ' 111 . .. ,...: — 14- litgir iip.., 1111 . ' ,..§: 4 :-;`'' - i --- i ' - 4' i ,, 1937709 ORD 03/21/2013 03:40:24 PM La t k. -. i. - , -.. , illa ,": ,,,,,....:!,,, .. Page: 4 of 5 R 31.00 D 0.00 T 31.00 ' ,.. :1 , ,, -1- . .‘ A.. `, v ." - •"' I ... II* j . Gilbert Ortiz Clerk/Recorder, Pueblo County, Co • 14dg If 'I "; ft 1 1 ' ''. 11' 1 l 1 - e' '' t ''' 4:. %IC' 1111 rinrii/ ANA riall iiii 11111 • t w 21st St , — - • a 1 ' ,„„..,,, 421 ;'' ' •••'. 7 , .: ' ;•.: Mk, 1 , ft .... 1 - "P'• ' • ""' "" li Ilig • `•= , 4 -` _ . r "11 "Ar " a 0 11 .116 AL ' '- -- . 17: _., i 7 . ..,..i... - . I , , ., 0 441 :11b.... ,...., 1 , , 161 .4 • „J._ 1 4 — ..:), g • - .... . ' -,7 • / ,_ ,. r -- , ,,,,,, . orc— ., 4.- ---, ' - .- iiik`":4 f' I S " • - " .4. 4.... ...„ : ,• ,, , ,, -,..„, , - .. 4: iw :or- ,-, -. -, , ,: 6 -- ' '. - 2 it -- ,,,,- ... _ . - 0 . • 4 i .0 ; . 'JO' ! -. Z:.: M - 1114":-'14 ii ' 411 .. !,.. ‘, , • , ,, ,,, - i ,, ' . ., - 11. 0 - - ' .c..... ) 0 1 '` ` '' 1 .• 1 ' • , , ' „,, ,,,,,,, o ,, 1 „ „. r , . -ot I II .', ''''''O''' ' k ' . . ' ' L - ''* ; IN 20th St ' ' - -- .' • , ....„. .. -.1 r4 , , - ..rnimur ..1«, C „ .light i.tiliii - .. . . __ _ ... . ' z .' li jiff .• - . rt, •.. ft s , Ali, 66 11_ 0 1 • fr, i „ Ileary4 t'' '...vir 0 ''. . idi- nut- . - wzirz-r-A idigenfra - mk.' '" ,, • mr,islig I , ., nwArs'A .1;' Gm" - Irk z ' ---- li ••-..-• ' ''' 4 ..",,' ilLrA j ' , 111 ' - I iN, -, n I ir- ? , i,o ig , i , _ , _ _ r____ -,••••____ , __. _ . ,, s , „„... . amPF9114 .4,1 I i wil pimp R,,, ogt, 2, Ili u4if -la lirlormig4 ..',;--4 Al -;,..f •;-'1 ' : ,.., - 4 , - . c oo.re ti l L 7 r ' mow ' .ts . " - 14 ' ii'' '..■' ' 04 , ." WNW IT Ai ' _____ i ii.&iiiiiit ! / • . . . --. -, r" , 4 -' ' ' ) .- ' _:. Apor . '4411 p ,..1 . Le ..... .. at.. .. I • ill .„ gil .0,- o 0 .* ,. 4131116111n--- at, _--- i' - " 1 ""k" . 11111111W. " 1 - W 19th St - - 04PrPik '4 ' • . _ ipli , A. .1 .060 i . 4.:„. . . L , i‘ 4,1,. . . . *4. I % ' • ' ..... ,,, At- il ; arty a . t 1 1 r . - • "WA =a Palace Park , ir I ,, , - i ,...1. , . ..'.. , . wlizi I . , - -,,i, ' Pt' - • .• ,... ,.., . o , . ..... so ...... , • - --1 ' • . - 4,.... ,. # . . 1 . - ,-- ; . - YE I k , rir ..' • i l . . , -4.P.)i-. . R. ' iii, , ,I.T. „ iii i il l IL ,;.: 0. or , ■ 4 ',. , ; laill1111 , II' 111 , 1 -._,. .,, wbk. .. '_ jo ilk 44.40 ''• 1--------• . • if Of ... . ' r. 1 1 I ' s. . •,,,. , ilik -lid • . 4-- , • ,., f r ' .. ..- '., , = '; . -: ..X.. . .., ... .. 111 , , - r •• - . . ... 1111,RM , i -L-1 7-7- - 1 ' Exhibit A. North Side Historic District _ , Ah... . . _, .. ..., , . . rf • . '. • 1. Phase II Final Map „ • - . A ; - : . , I W 16th St •• . _-• - ..,. voci r r A Opt Out Properties ,. • :''' k. - • r 1 ra , io.; ifit : - .,.. — ' 2. ..... Phase 11 Historic District Boundary „, ,.... ._' i : 1 • , : , - . • — — SW - ; , Phase 11 Landmark Properties ',-,- _Ilk. • • , Parkview Hospital ; 4 • I ....,..,"...•..... - , 4 _ , ' . .,. , . _ ' ‘ City of Pueblo rt . i .; 400 Planning & Community , _ —,y i Development ; . . ,..., ' 0- ....,,,, , : rm. 1, , 1 1 03/04/2013 pumt...,... . ,. • , _ __ Exhibit B. North Side Historic District Phase II Final Property List Historic Property Name Opt Out Residences Property Address Year Built District Contrib. James R. and Della M. Davies House In 207 W. 19th Street 1909 Yes James L. Lovern House In 209 W. 19th Street 1908 Yes Benjamin Franklin Koperlik House In 307 W. 19th Street 1921 Yes Judge J. Arthur Phelps House In 309 W. 19th Street 1922 Yes . t William Peach House In 311 W. 19th Street 1923 Yes Frank and Alice McAvoy House In 411 W. 19th Street 1929 Yes CO Bi a Samuel R. Risley House In 415 W. 19th Street 1906 Yes am Royal W. Olson House In 419 W. 19th Street 1913 Yes VE j nal Dr. Edwin W. Varley House In 425 W. 19th Street 1904 Yes 7.1_ George B. Eberenz In 519 W. 19th Street 1903 Yes N 3 David M. Campbell House In 521 W. 19th Street 1903 Yes ni a J. Robert and Lena D. Duckworth House In 619 W.19th Street 1914 Yes M . ' CD li Leold "Leo" Guggenheim House In 621 W. 19th Street 1911 Yes m N" O Edward C. Teller House In 625 W. 19th Street 1909 Yes • N Morton and Ruth Rechnitz House In 416 W. 20th Street 1929 Yes m • Y Everett Day Duplex In 418 -420 W. 20th Stree 1930 Yes m , m g William R. and Vera M. Dunn House In 614 W.20th Street 1952 Yes Leonard C. Gibbens House In 622 W. 20th Street 1915 Yes e Adelbert A. Weiland House In 1910 Court Street 1914 Yes o Ralph B. Ferris House In 1912 -1914 Court StreE 1908 No co Robert Anderson House; John Frederick In 1917 Court Street 1904 Yes M ro Rolland L. Phillips House In 1922 Court Street 1923 Yes ' ?-4 a -. BE Kenneth V. and Ruth R. Means House In 1926 Court Street 1956 No Charles T. Strots House In 1927 Court Street 1900 Yes Edwin E. Churchill House In 1930 Court Street 1896 Yes Edward Frederick Brown House In 1901 N. Elizabeth Stre 1904 Yes La Mont B. Beach House In 1909 N. Elizabeth Stre 1909 No Helander -King House In 1910 N. Elizabeth Stre 1900 Yes John H. Jenkins House In 1911 N. Elizabeth Stre 1904 Yes Edwin E. Douglass House In 1914 N. Elizabeth Stre 1906 Yes Edgar T. Pate House In 1915 N. Elizabeth Stre• 1923 Yes ila John W. Davidson House In 1919 N. Elizabeth Stre 1902 Yes — Brooking- Howard House In 1921 N. Elizabeth Stre 1900 -01 (o Yes Kenneth McCabe House In 1922 N. Elizabeth Stre 1920 No Max Schwer House In 1924 N. Elizabeth Stre 1914 Yes 8 Edward V. Garnett House In 1925 N. Elizabeth Stre 1904 Yes i. Finney -Clark House In 1930 N. Elizabeth Stre 1913 Yes Cm Albert Elliot House In 1901 N. Grand Avenue 1908 Yes a , ; o William Henry House In 1903 N. Grand Avenue 1908 Yes N� o Clarence B. Douglas House In 1912 N. Grand AvenuE 1924 Yes m ~ — m Eugene F. Ford House In 1913 N. Grand AvenuE 1903 Yes ••092 Edward J. Scott House In 1915 N.Grand Avenue 1888 Yes mm Paul L. Wright House In 1918 N. Grand AvenuE 1929 Yes roc • N 0 � John H. Crow House In 1919 N.Grand Avenue 1909 Yes o Lloyd H. Benning House In 1921 N.Grand Avenue 1920 Yes . Jacob Blum House In 1922 N. Grand AvenuE 1905 Yes N Ralph H. Redak House In 1925 N. Grand AvenuE 1926 Yes mix m t Louis W. Biele House In 1930 N. Grand AvenuE 1900 Yes — re Nancy J. Mize House In 1912 N. Greenwood 511903 Yes .- Ambrose V. Bradford House In 1915 N. Greenwood 511890 Yes ON -0 Robert Kershaw House In 1916 N. Greenwood Si 1901 Yes r! • • co Mary and Mabel Meyers House In 1917 N. Greenwood 511906 Yes ro Dr. Augustus J. Monahan House In 1918 N. Greenwood St 1903 Yes " - a 101 Jesse A. Rood House In 1919 N. Greenwood 511899 -1900 No Milton C. Potter House In 1920 N.Greenwood St 1903 Yes William Peach House In 1925 N. Greenwood 511903 Yes Morris C. Johnson House In 1927 N. Greenwood 511906 Yes Walter E. Scott Sr. House In 1911 N. Main Street 1904 Yes Willard S. Kettering House In 1915 N. Main Street 1926 Yes Walter E. Scott House In 1929 N. Main Street 1911 Yes Dr. Ray R. Taylor House In 1908 West Street 1919 Yes Robert C. Innes House In 1912 West Street 1921 Yes Background Paper for Proposed ORDINANCE DATE: NOVEMBER 26, 2012 AGENDA ITEM # R-10 DEPARTMENT: PLANNING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT JULIE ANN WOODS, AICP/ASLA, DIRECTOR TITLE AN ORDINANCE DESIGNATING THE NORTH SIDE LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT, PHASE II ISSUE Should City Council designate the North Side Local Historic District, Phase II, as a local Pueblo Historic District, pursuant to the Historic Preservation Code, Title IV, Chapter 14 of the Pueblo Municipal Code? RECOMMENDATION Adoption of the Ordinance, as recommended by staff of the Department of Planning and Community Development. The Historic Preservation Commission at their November 8, 2012 Regular Meeting voted 6-0 to recommend approval. A Motion to Approve the District by the Planning and Zoning Commission at their November 14, 2012 Regular Meeting failed by a 2-3 vote. No reasons were given by the Planning and Zoning Commission as to why they did not support the extension of the District. BACKGROUND The North Side Local Historic District, Phase II, was submitted for designation as a local Pueblo Historic District as an extension of the first North Side Historic District that was approved in 2007 by the Old Northside Neighborhood Organization. The proposed area contains 84 residential buildings, and 78 were determined to be eligible as contributing buildings. The neighborhood is significant because it contains homes that represent a broad spectrum of architectural styles from 1872 to 1955 and was the home of Pueblo’s business and entrepreneurial elite. Pueblo’s North Side neighborhood was one of the first planned communities with graded streets, tree lined avenues, and model homes. The HPC has recommended that City Council allow residents 60 days to ‘opt out’ of the historic district by providing a notarized letter making the request to the City Planning Director. Owners who do not object in writing will be included in the proposed historic district. Findings of Staff and the Historic Preservation Commission, and the draft minutes of the Planning and Zoning Commission are attached. FINANCIAL IMPACT No financial impact.